Tuesday, September 29, 2020

 




Link to Book: 
I will try to answer any questions or consider any comments.



Book Synopsis
Have you ever asked yourself how much Christ charged for his blessings, miracles, and ordinances? Not many people have thought about that, but we ought to, since a typical LDS member pays out about $500,000 as the cost of a lifetime membership in the LDS church. The truth is that Christ charged nothing for his services, which ought to make one wonder about the extreme expense of belonging to today's LDS church. But, even worse, the present arrangement almost precludes anyone from engaging in serious New Testament-mandated charity work, since all the money one might reasonably have available to do charity work is claimed by the church headquarters, where only about 1% of the money that is received there is actually used for humanitarian aid. So, when was it that Christ came back in person to undo and reverse everything that he did earlier, which included ending the law of Moses and beginning a New Testament charity-based gospel system? Did he or Moses personally come back to re-institute today's law of Moses-style highly profitable professional ministry where a single member might be expected to contribute $500,000 in membership fees in a lifetime? I know of no such momentous event being recorded of Christ reappearing to reverse all that he accomplished with his earthly life.

Christ completely ended the old law of Moses, and that included ending the old law of tithing, and the huge paid ministry of the tribe of Levites that was supported by that tithing. From then on, every man was to be his own priest, so there was no need to have a paid ministry. Christ also did away with any need for any expensive fixed Temple such as the Temple of Solomon or the Temple of Herod. Under the new church rules that took effect during and after the life of Christ, the church members had access to all the higher priesthood ordinances, including all the sealing ordinances such as eternal marriage, and yet they had no requirement to build any chapels or any temples. That meant that they could retain all of their personal resources and use them to actually live the New Testament law of charity by taking good care of their friends and neighbors. This also made them very mobile, since they had no need for any particular physical structure to fully engage in their religion.

As a practical matter, the church can have either charity or tithing, but not both. Charity was the only church welfare and finance system in effect for at least 300 years after Christ, as was also true at the beginning of this dispensation under the guidance of Joseph Smith. However, in 1896, Wilford Woodruff decided to begin using tithing for church leadership salaries, and all the current leaders (except one) began pressing very hard to reinstitute the old law of Moses version of tithing to increase central church revenue. It took a long time to become fully successful in that policy change as the church members resisted (but apparently offered no organized principled resistance), but now we have almost completely removed charity as a practical church activity and replaced it with the requirement to send 10% of our annual resources to the central church offices where it is poorly used or simply stockpiled.



The above materials describe book 5 in a set of 5, part of larger project entitled "An Analytical History Of The LDS Church" described below. All 5 books are now available on Amazon:


An Analytical History Of The LDS Church

in five volumes, by Kent Huff

 

An issue-oriented intellectual history of the LDS church, exploring some of the great questions concerning human life on earth as raised and answered by the history of the restoration of Christ's church.

 

Some questions:

●What did early LDS leaders teach about the need and correct methods for concerted action in making the restoration of the church a successful reality? What effects have ideological issues and factions, inside and outside the church, had on the course of LDS church history?

 

●How did the LDS church affect slavery and the Civil War, and how was the LDS church affected by those issues and events?

 

●How did church members govern themselves before Utah statehood, in the absence of access to most normal government functions?

 

●What do the historical experiences of the LDS church teach us about God's concept of individual freedom?

 

●How has the New Testament concept of individual charity been woven into church history? How does it relate to attempts at concerted action?

 

●What is the growth history of the LDS church and what is the situation today? What should it be? What do those statistics tell us about church history and doctrine?

 

●What ideas for stimulating growth have been tried, and which have NOT been tried? Are there theological or practical reasons for the church currently being in a no-growth situation?

 

●How does the 2020 A.D. LDS church compare with the 33 A.D. Church which Christ himself organized during his lifetime? If there are important differences, what does that mean?

 

Book summaries in publication sequence:

 

Joseph Smith’s United Order: A Non-Communalistic Interpretation (1988, 2020)

Joseph Smith staunchly maintained the political and religious freedom of the Saints and resisted every attempt to require some religious-based communalism which might limit individual property rights and other freedoms. Unfortunately, the theologians of centralization and priestcraft are always active, whether in religion or in government, and Joseph Smith resisted them all. As a further misfortune, Joseph's vigorous teachings and efforts in the cause of freedom have been largely forgotten. There was indeed a "united order" or "united firm" set up by Joseph Smith, but it was nothing more than a small common-law partnership organized to conduct central church business before it was even politically possible to have such a thing as a corporation of the president to handle these matters as we do today.

 

Brigham Young’s United Order: A Contextual Interpretation, Vol. 1, Main Presentation (1998, 2020)

The general theme of this book concerns all the unusual ideas and actions that needed to be invented by church leaders to adapt for the fact that the church members often had no access to ordinary government processes which would allow them to solve their normal social problems in a straightforward and constitutional way in Utah. This difficult situation occurred for a short time in Nauvoo and Winter Quarters before the Saints even made it to Utah. Also, wagon trains and handcart companies have their own special needs for governance. The first 22 years the Saints were in Utah, from 1847 to 1869, were especially difficult, and their lack of access to ordinary government processes continued until they were finally granted statehood in 1896. To be more specific, for many years there was no legal way to own land, form lasting business organizations, enforce criminal law, etc. Some of the church-invented solutions to these governing difficulties are known by such often-misunderstood terms as united order, blood atonement, Adam-god, etc. Without a fairly deep understanding of the practical problems which the Saints faced during those years, these unusual terms are incomprehensible to modern-day church members.

 

Brigham Young’s United Order: A Contextual Interpretation, Vol. 2, Related Anomalies and Side Issues (1998, 2020)

The individual opinions of 9 different church leaders are explored on some of the more unusual discussion topics of their time – united orders, polygamy, blood atonement, Adam-god, etc.

 

Creating The Millennium: Social Forces and Church Growth in the 21st Century (2004, 2020)

Spreading the knowledge and the benefits of the gospel is what brings about a condition known as Zion, or the Millennium. This book explores the statistics of growth for the LDS church, and suggests some creative measures that might be taken to speed up the spread of the gospel and the growth of the church. The book raises the question as to why church growth rates have been shrinking since about 1960 until they have reached zero, or nearly so, but the book is unable to suggest an answer.

 

Is The Church As True As The Gospel? A Constitutional Approach (2020)

This book finally approaches head-on the question of why church growth is approximately at zero. The simple but unexpected and shocking answer is that while Christ's original church was perfectly adapted for spreading worldwide, the current version of the church is not correctly adapted. Increasing the pressure on members to achieve more with a faulty message would be counterproductive. Just as the idiosyncratic and tribal nature of the law of Moses kept that religion from spreading to anyone besides the Jews and other Israelites, the church today has many of the same features as that Jewish church, and cannot practically grow beyond the current idiosyncratic and tribal nature of current pioneer-stock Mormons who are still bound together more because of their own pioneer Exodus heritage than by the force of actual gospel teachings and practices. Only when today's church reverts back to the original configuration of the church as it existed just after the life of Christ, and as Joseph Smith restored it, can today's church expand any further or have any hope of bringing the world to a millennial condition as predicted in the Scriptures.

 

The largest change needed is to end today's Old Testament tithing and professional priesthood system, and replace all of it with individualized New Testament charity practices. That basically means dismantling the current headquarters unit and dispersing essentially all priesthood and operating authority to the stake levels. That would return us to the original New Testament church organization pattern. That localization of everything would allow the church to quickly spread worldwide and to begin a rapid preparation for Zion and the millennial condition. This is consistent with the scripture-based concept of post-millennialism wherein church activity demonstrates the power of the gospel and brings the world to a near-millennial state, a condition which would allow Christ to come and give his approval and complete the process.

 

Five historical phases can be identified for the modern church:

1.  The original church is restored and remains intact for 66 years.

2.  The decision is made to follow the path of the Catholic Church to reinstitute the law of Moses, essentially creating the Catholic Church version 2. A majority of church leaders in 1896 took advantage of the chaotic practical and ideological conditions to confuse and exploit the Saints. Where Christ had fastidiously resisted all temptations of the devil concerning potential earthly power, the fourth set of church leaders, led by Wilford Woodruff, eagerly embraced those temptations. Note that these church leaders took action only AFTER the church's major existential crises were over and it had finally become profitable to exploit the Saints when they finally had some income beyond that needed for their bare survival. Brigham Young feared this very outcome could occur when the Saints emerged from the mere subsistence level.

3.  By 1960 the law of Moses is fully implemented and the church begins to die.

4.  Zero net growth is reached by 2018, and the dead husk of the LDS Church lingers on. Its futile efforts to build an earthly empire languish. Unless it chooses to "restore the restoration" it can go no further. It might consider using greater levels of police-state-style coercion to expand its earthly empire, but, more likely, such policies would hasten its disintegration in a free nation. The no-growth equilibrium point it has achieved could go on indefinitely until there is some outside disrupting factor such as general social unrest. The China virus has shown how quickly the church could become socially irrelevant.

5. Ideally, the church would completely reform itself and experience the great future successes prophesied.

 

 



Tuesday, June 2, 2020








Book Synopsis
Have you ever asked yourself how much Christ charged for his blessings, miracles, and ordinances? Not many people have thought about that, but we ought to, since a typical LDS member pays out about $500,000 as the cost of a lifetime membership in the LDS church. The truth is that Christ charged nothing for his services, which ought to make one wonder about the extreme expense of belonging to today's LDS church. But, even worse, the present arrangement almost precludes anyone from engaging in serious New Testament-mandated charity work, since all the money one might reasonably have available to do charity work is claimed by the church headquarters, where only about 1% of the money that is received there is actually used for humanitarian aid. So, when was it that Christ came back in person to undo and reverse everything that he did earlier, which included ending the law of Moses and beginning a New Testament charity-based gospel system? Did he or Moses personally come back to re-institute today's law of Moses-style highly profitable professional ministry where a single member might be expected to contribute $500,000 in membership fees in a lifetime? I know of no such momentous event being recorded of Christ reappearing to reverse all that he accomplished with his earthly life.

Christ completely ended the old law of Moses, and that included ending the old law of tithing, and the huge paid ministry of the tribe of Levites that was supported by that tithing. From then on, every man was to be his own priest, so there was no need to have a paid ministry. Christ also did away with any need for any expensive fixed Temple such as the Temple of Solomon or the Temple of Herod. Under the new church rules that took effect during and after the life of Christ, the church members had access to all the higher priesthood ordinances, including all the sealing ordinances such as eternal marriage, and yet they had no requirement to build any chapels or any temples. That meant that they could retain all of their personal resources and use them to actually live the New Testament law of charity by taking good care of their friends and neighbors. This also made them very mobile, since they had no need for any particular physical structure to fully engage in their religion.

As a practical matter, the church can have either charity or tithing, but not both. Charity was the only church welfare and finance system in effect for at least 300 years after Christ, as was also true at the beginning of this dispensation under the guidance of Joseph Smith. However, in 1896, Wilford Woodruff decided to begin using tithing for church leadership salaries, and all the current leaders (except one) began pressing very hard to reinstitute the old law of Moses version of tithing to increase central church revenue. It took a long time to become fully successful in that policy change as the church members resisted (but apparently offered no organized principled resistance), but now we have almost completely removed charity as a practical church activity and replaced it with the requirement to send 10% of our annual resources to the central church offices where it is poorly used or simply stockpiled.